Ice cream pie

Ice cream pie recipes have been around for centuries, with the earliest known recipe dating back to the 16th century. The first ice cream pies were made with a crust of ice cream, which was then filled with a variety of fruits and nuts. These pies were then frozen and served as a dessert.

The first recipe for an ice cream pie was published in the 18th century by a French cookbook. This recipe called for a crust of ice cream, which was then filled with a variety of fruits and nuts. The pie was then frozen and served as a dessert.

In the 19th century, ice cream pies became more popular in the United States. The first known recipe for an ice cream pie in the US was published in 1851. This recipe called for a crust of graham crackers, which was then filled with ice cream and topped with a meringue.

Jump to: Ingredient Breakdown Insights

Recipes

  /public/bonappetit-logo.svg

Salted PB&J Ice Cream Pie

  • FILLING AND ASSEMBLY
  • vanilla extract
  • heavy cream
  • light
  • peanut butter
  • salt
  • grape jelly
  • egg
  • CRUST
  • sleeve ritz cracker
  • salt
  • peanut
  • light
  • butter
  /public/thespruceeats-logo.svg

Mississippi Mud Ice Cream Pie

  • bourbon
  • chocolate cookie
  • brown sugar
  • pecan
  • vanilla extract
  • sugar
  • light corn syrup
  • vanilla ice cream
  • bourbon
  • butter
  • heavy cream
  • chocolate
  • sweetened whipped cream
  /public/foodnetwork-logo.svg

Chocolate Banana Ice Cream Pie

  • light brown sugar
  • vanilla extract
  • vanilla bean
  • heavy cream
  • milk
  • peanut
  • light corn syrup
  • sugar
  • hot coffee
  • butter
  • banana
  • chocolate wafer
  • dutch cocoa
  • semisweet chocolate
  • semisweet chocolate
  • butter
  • eggs yolk
  • fork
  /public/bonappetit-logo.svg

Coconut-Strawberry Ice Cream Pie

  • CRUST
  • cooking spray
  • coconut
  • virgin coconut oil
  • salt
  • graham cracker
  • FILLING AND ASSEMBLY
  • lemon juice
  • sugar
  • coconut ice cream
  • strawberry ice cream
  • strawberry
  /public/foodnetwork-logo.svg

Chocolate-Caramel Banana Ice Cream Pie

  • filling
  • glaze
  • vanilla extract
  • light corn syrup
  • milk chocolate
  • heavy cream
  • sugar
  • banana
  • cartons vanilla ice cream
  • dulce de leche
  • butter
  • chocolate graham cracker sheet
  /public/the-country-cook-logo.svg

Mint Chip Ice Cream Pie

  • andes mint chocolate
  • heavy cream
  • mint extract
  • sweetened condensed milk
  • powdered sugar
  • oreo cooky
  • butter
  • green coloring
  /public/home-sick-texan-logo.webp

Mexican coffee ice cream pie

  • heavy cream
  • dark chocolate
  • orange zest
  • vanilla extract
  • cream cheese
  • graham cracker
  • sweetened condensed milk
  • cinnamon
  • coffee
  • brown sugar
  • cocoa powder
  • sugar
  • butter
  • cinnamon
  /public/saveur-logo.webp

Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream Pie

  • sugar
  • vanilla bean
  • heavy cream
  • pumpkin
  • vanilla extract
  • nutmeg pod
  • graham cracker crumb
  • milk
  • cinnamon
  • clove
  • egg yolk
  • butter
  /public/love-from-the-oven-logo.svg

Chocolate Ice Cream Pie

  • premade chocolate cookie pie crust
  • tsbp light corn syrup
  • heavy cream
  • breyers chocolate ice cream
  • butter
  • sweet chocolate chip
  /public/bonappetit-logo.svg

Rocky Road Ice Cream Pie

  • ch pie
  • salt
  • smoked
  • whipped cream
  • marshmallow
  • pecan
  • butter
  • caramel sauce
  • sugar
  • rye flour
  • magic shell chocolate
  • egg
  • chocolate
  • dark chocolate wafer
  • milk chocolate wafer
  • butter
  • chocolate wafer cooky

Ingredient Breakdown

 
butter
heavy cream
sugar
vanilla extract
salt
vanilla ice cream
light corn syrup
oreo cooky
peanut butter
peanut
chocolate
banana
cinnamon
light
egg
bourbon
brown sugar
pecan
coconut
chocolate ice cream
vanilla bean
milk
semisweet chocolate
strawberry ice cream
strawberry
ice cream
lemon juice
graham cracker
filling
dulce de leche
sweetened condensed milk
caramel sauce
oreo ice cream
oreo cookie crumb crust
chocolate syrup
sleeve ritz cracker
grape jelly
chocolate cookie
sweetened whipped cream
confectioners sugar
vanilla wafer cooky
light brown sugar
hot coffee
chocolate wafer
dutch cocoa
eggs yolk
fork
rice cereal
white karo syrup
crisped rice cereal
cooking spray
virgin coconut oil
coconut ice cream
glaze
milk chocolate
cartons vanilla ice cream
chocolate graham cracker sheet
andes mint chocolate
mint extract
powdered sugar
green coloring
buttermilk
chocolate covered caramel
baking soda
graham cracker crust
dark chocolate
orange zest
cream cheese
coffee
cocoa powder
nonstick spray
waffle cone
crust
chocolate sprinkle
egg white
cookie crumb
pumpkin
nutmeg pod
graham cracker crumb
clove
egg yolk
oreo
snickers bar
chocolate magic shell
miniature heath bar
heath bar
hot caramel sauce
hot fudge sauce
pre made cookie
sprinkle
premade chocolate cookie pie crust
tsbp light corn syrup
breyers chocolate ice cream
sweet chocolate chip
ch pie
smoked
whipped cream
marshmallow
rye flour
magic shell chocolate
dark chocolate wafer
milk chocolate wafer
chocolate wafer cooky
premade oreo cookie pie crust
peppermint ice cream
chocolate fudge ice cream
candy cane
non dairy whipped cream

Insights

Correlated with Lower Ratings

  • butter

Staple Ingredients

  • butter 48%

Usual Ingredients

  • heavy cream 38%
  • sugar 33%
  • vanilla extract 33%